Praying It's A Sign PDF Print
Written by Jonathan Higbee | Wednesday, 29 July 2009
Tags: Catholicism, gay, study, GLBT rights

I like things shaken, not stirred, and the latest developments in religion v. gay rights certainly make for a stunning martini, darlings.

Jeffrey Lax and Justin Phillips, in a not-yet-published study for Columbia University, have found that states with higher Catholic populations offer more gay rights. That’s right, you read it correctly – more, more, more.

The study found that Catholic majorities favor health benefits, as well as hate crime and discrimination protections for their GLBT neighbors, but -- sad face -- oppose marriage equality and adoptions.

However, as Mark Silk from Spiritual Politics points out, recent numbers out of the American Religious Identification Survey might challenge the aforementioned aspect of the Columbia report, showing that six of eight states with more than 50% public support for marriage equality are also the six highest Catholic-populated states.

As a Catholic school alumnus, I’ve been embedded with what has arguably and often amounted to a gay rights “enemy.” From my time in bed with Catholics (pun intended) it's clear that these recent confusing statistics highlight an internal discrepancy in the faith’s approach to GLBT rights: on one side, at the heart of Catholicism lies a foundation of loving all human beings unconditionally sans judgment; while the rank and file of the Church insists on intolerance and vilification.

While it’s not clear if the latest statistics will get an Amen! from the GLBT community, I’m starting a countdown for the conservative spin on the findings to ensue in 3, 2, 1…

 

Comments (3)Add Comment
RJTamayo
...
written by RJTamayo, July 29, 2009
You're right Jonathan. Being a product of 12 years of Catholic school myself, I know the rank and file Catholics finds their intolerance as justifiable. They see any Catholic that supports gay rights as not "true" Catholics, even though the true Catholic nature is to question everything. I'm more of mind of Mahatma Ghandi who said:

"I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ".
jhigbee
...
written by jhigbee, July 29, 2009
Best. Ghandi quote. Ever.
cdavis
...
written by cdavis, July 29, 2009
I agree...

Write comment

busy
 
 
 
© 2009 Instinct Magazine  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Web Site By Nathan Grimes Design