VIDEO: Rachel Maddow Asks: Does Dr. Spitzer's Rejection Of Ex-Gay Therapy Impact The Prop. 8 Case? PDF Print
Written by Instinct Staff | Sunday, 29 April 2012
Tags: rachel maddow, the rachel maddow show, proposition 8, prop 8, marriage equality, prop 8 trial, dr. robert spitzer, ex-gay therapy, reparative therapy, retraction

maddowww

Rachel Maddow has raised an interesting question: now that Dr. Robert Spitzer has formally debunked his own 2001 study that claimed highly motivated men and women could modify their sexual orientation, what are the ramifications of this with regards to the Prop. 8 Trial, which may battle its way all the way to the US Supreme Court?

Defendants of Prop. 8 heavily hinged their argument, in court, on Spitzer's study and the "evidence" that gays and lesbians could simply change their orientation, thereby meaning they weren't being denied rights. They could simply choose to be straight, and get married.

Now that their main "proof" of this is kaput, what does that do to their case?

Video after the jump.

 

Maddow states: “It was important for the lawyer on the anti-gay side to get it on the record that this prominent study by this prominent expert psychiatrist proved that gay people can change.  It is relatively central to their argument that denying gay people access to marriage isn't some kind of second class citizenship for gay people. Gay people have first class citizenship, all they have to do is change into straight people and then they can have all the rights they want.”

“That argument has just fallen apart.”

What do you think, Instincters? Could this be a break in the case for marriage equality?

 

Image Source

Comments (1)Add Comment
0
...
written by marcus816, April 30, 2012
Rachel Maddow, Smartest person in the universe or just the smartest person on earth?

Write comment

busy
 
 
 
© 2009 Instinct Magazine  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Web Site By Nathan Grimes Design