What's Your Instinct: Did Jackie Beat's AIDS Joke Cross The Line As Critics Suggest? PDF Print
Written by Instinct Staff | Friday, 02 March 2012
Tags: jackie beat, aids joke, madonna, twitter, facebook, social network, what's your instinct, humor, drag queens, gay

jackie

Drag queen Jackie Beat is known for her trademark irreverent humor, but did a joke she made on Twitter on Wednesday that has sparked a backlash really cross the line, as her critics are accusing?

“I’ll admit Madonna’s new song is catchy…But so is AIDS," Jackie Tweeted on Wednesday.

The retaliations poured in instantaneously, with comments like:

"I wonder how all of you lighthearted queens would react if you actually had HIV. Millions of people die from it still in areas of the world where medicine is scarce and expensive, and I can assure you, they would not be laughing at this. I love some of Jackie's work, but this is just bad taste, unless you actually have HIV."

"Sorry but comparing a Madonna song to AIDS is nothing short of disgusting! Shame on you Jackie Beat!"

Most of Jackie's fans and followers supported her comment, however, with some writing: 

"Its a drag queen making a joke, No where do I see Jackie supporting the disease in an encouraging way. Unless you ARE madonna with HIV then get a life and maybe check out a drag show or something. The world isn't ending- go to bed."

"If "the gays" can't co-exist in a country with free speech how can we ever expect equal rights? We are our own worst enemy. And P.S. Comedy exists to make the unbearable more tolerable, keep up the good work Jackie Beat. If we can past our fear of this word, perhaps we can eradicate it. But first, the Jews!"

Jackie defended herself by responding: 

“Go tell it to a Jew who makes Holocaust jokes or Black comic who uses the word “nigger”…If a 48 year-old faggot drag queen cannot make an AIDS joke then who the fuck can? Let me guess… NO ONE? Go watch “Joan Rivers: A Piece of Work” and get back to me.”

What do you think, Instincters? Did Jackie Beat's joke go too far as some have claimed? 

(Photographer credit: Austin Young; Image source: Queerty)

Comments (57)Add Comment
 1 2 3 > 
..., Low-rated comment [Show]
..., Low-rated comment [Show]
0
...
written by stephan, March 02, 2012
anyone familiar with Jackie Beat and her humor knows what to expect. Don't think she's funny? Then don't befriend her on Facebook and don't see her shows. I personally appreciate that Jackie's type of humor delineates those with a sense of humor and those who are humorless twats.
..., Low-rated comment [Show]
..., Low-rated comment [Show]
0
...
written by Jojo , March 02, 2012
Oh good lord. Jackie has a nasty streak and that's why we love her. People are so in love with being offended. Team Jackie.
0
...
written by AdamW, March 02, 2012
I agree with Jojo. Some people are addicted to outrage. Get over it! Jackie Beat is awesome. Comedy is all about playing off people's anxieties - every comedian is going to step on someone's toes along the way.
0
...
written by gregg paz, March 02, 2012
If you cant take a joke, shut the fuck up! Come on, really? In this day and age, gays will over react to anything! Lighten up, my people!!! Jackie SAYS, what you ALL THINK! Please kick the soap box out from under your feet and come back down to reality like the rest of us. If ANY of you that are criticizing her were at a party and someone told that joke, you would laugh your ass off, not go in the next room and anonymously trash talk the person. Shame on you !!
0
...
written by Jackie Beat, March 02, 2012
Like I've said before, any comedian who is on Twitter should really call their next show "Giving It Away For Free, One Line At A Time!" Please note that I never attached the label "joke" to this Tweet, so whether it's funny or not doesn't necessarily mean that the single sentence fails as what it is: A MERE THOUGHT. Also, anyone who feels like they somehow didn't get their money's worth should be reminded that what I saw on Twitter and Facebook is, in fact, free! "Drag is supposed to be glamorous, classy and fun." Yes and comedians should be non-threatening clowns who only do jokes about those little packets of peanuts you get on an airplane or a kooky blind date, but I guess that's why Roseanne Barr (the original loud-mouthed big girl!) called me "The Lenny Bruce of drag." I'll wait while the Gaga fans Google him. To anyone who doesn't think I'm funny, I say this: Guess what? There are some men out there who actually prefer vagina over penises, too. We're all different! That's the beauty of it! So stop telling me what is and isn't funny, asshole! And will someone please forward me the list of topics that are completely off-limits to comedians. Thanks!
0
...
written by mysti, March 02, 2012
"Why take life so seriously? None of us are getting out of it alive, anyway." - Anonymous
0
...
written by JoelWG, March 02, 2012
Jackie is a comedian that told a joke. End of story.
0
...
written by Robert A., March 02, 2012
Queens?!?! It's a joke!! I'd hate to do this but-
"If you can take a dick, you can take a joke!"
-Tracy Morgan
0
...
written by Sister Indica, March 02, 2012
Jackie Beat's humor is offensive...that's kind of her thing. If Instinct were to post an article every time Jackie said something offensive, they may as well call their publication "The Beat". This is also probably the tamest joke she's ever told. Lighten UP!
0
...
written by Hektoreo, March 02, 2012
Cowards can not laugh at life. It's not like Jackie crated AIDS.
0
...
written by Hektoreo, March 02, 2012
Createdsmilies/grin.gif
0
...
written by Tea Parker, March 02, 2012
South park makes fun of aids, cancer everything. If you take offense to a joke, then it says something about you, and not the joke. Humor should have no boundaries if it's going to be grande. Otherwise we're talking about lukewarm political correctness. Someone is bound to get offended with one joke or another. If you think people should make jokes while checking a list of complexes that people will respond to, then that is a failed comedy.
Go Jackie!
0
...
written by Hardly offensive, March 02, 2012
Please! Do you want to live in a world where we can't make jokes? Aids IS catchy! Get over it.
0
...
written by No hablo ingles., March 02, 2012
I hate americans!!!!! here jackie, Now your aids joke is soooo 5 minutes ago...come on guys....start yelling at me. guess what!!!! i do not give a fuck so is jackie. Freedom of speech. FERME TA GEULE.
0
...
written by Curtisjunk, March 02, 2012
When did queers get so humorless? Jackie makes me laugh. period.
0
...
written by WD, March 02, 2012
It was a joke. It was funny BECAUSE it was offensive. If it wasn't offensive, it wouldn't be funny.
 1 2 3 > 

Write comment
You can add your comment here

busy
 
 
 
© 2009 Instinct Magazine  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Web Site By Nathan Grimes Design