What's Your Instinct: Gay Man Sues Employer For Explicitly Pro-Gay Hiring Practices PDF Print
Written by Instinct Staff | Thursday, 10 May 2012
Tags: jamie ardigo, christopher burch, j. christopher capital, pro-gay hiring practices, sexual orientation discrimination, employment discrimination, lawsuit, whats your instinct

gty jamie_ardigo_chris_burch_ll_120509_wg

So here's an interesting question: Can an employer like gay employees too much?

Gay, human resources professional, Jamie Ardigo, is suing his former employer, J. Christopher Capital, after he was allegedly fired for trying to change the company's "discriminatory practices."

Ardigo charges that the owner of the company, Christopher Burch, uniformly discriminated against straight men (and ugly women??), choosing to only hire gay men and "beautiful women." 

More after the jump.

Burch's alleged reasoning for his hiring practices? Gay men are "productive" and "he trusts them." Ardigo explains, "I witnessed it in meetings with the executive management team, where he'd blatantly state the fact that he only likes to hire gay men and beautiful women."

For his part, Ardigo was offended, both as a gay man and as a human resources professional. ABC News explains that as an "HR professional 'keenly aware' of the need to maintain a non-discriminatory atmosphere in the workplace, he knew that both the attitude expressed and any hiring that bore it out was contrary to federal and New York City law."

Ardigo continues, "I was highly concerned for the organization and uncomfortable myself working there. I had never worked for an organization that made decisions based on that or that made comments like that."

He feels that he was ultimately fired for bringing attention to discriminatory practices and inappropriate behavior. He also felt pressure to reveal information about himself that he deemed private.

Regarding his supervisor, Ardigo says, "He stated that he needed to trust me, and in order to do that he needed to know more about me. Knowing the culture of the organization, hearing about their hiring only gay men, I felt there was an expectation that I had to reveal that information in order to be successful at work."

He found this pressure "highly inappropriate."

Burch and J. Christopher Capital deny any wrongdoing. They also claim that Ardigo's firing was based on "a performance-related issue."

What do you think, Instincters? Yes, we've been called worse things than "productive" and "trustworthy." That said, can we excuse work place discrimination against straight men and less-than-beautiful women?

Is it acceptable for our sexual orientation to be a reason why we're hired?

What's your, Instinct?

 

Image Source

Comments (3)Add Comment
0
...
written by kadield, May 10, 2012
Sexual Orientation should never, ever be a reason why you're hired/hired. EVER.
0
...
written by Fungud, May 10, 2012
Let's not do the whole false equivalency thing and pretend that this is in any way as shitty as getting denied a job because you're gay.
Uptonking
...
written by Uptonking, May 11, 2012
Wow. This makes my head hurt. File under bizarre. Do you think Jamie Ardigo is one of those politically-confused log cabin people? Or is he just looking for a payday? Besides... everybody knows ugly women make for the best employees. Who they got but their cats? (jk)

Write comment

busy
 
 
 
© 2009 Instinct Magazine  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Web Site By Nathan Grimes Design