What's Your Instinct: Should Maya Rudolph Impersonate Whitney Houston On This Weekend's 'SNL'? PDF Print
Written by Instinct Staff | Wednesday, 15 February 2012
Tags: saturday night live, snl, whitney houston, considers, maya rudolph, host, impersonation, divas, tv, too soon

Maya rudolph_whitney_300120214082525

In a world with a 24-hour news cycle and the ability to update followers in 140 characters every few seconds, is there such a thing as "too soon?" Saturday Night Live might test the limits of those archaic words this weekend when one of its most-uproarious veterans, Maya Rudolph, hosts the venerable show. Rumor has it that SNL writers and producers are considering writing a sketch around one of Maya's most well-known celebrity impersonations, Whitney Houston. 

With Whitney's funeral set for Saturday across the river from 30 Rock in Newark, the timing could be even more delicate. 

But Michael Slezak at Deadline imagines a few sketches in which a "too soon" Whitney sketch might actually be tasteful:

1 | Whitney judges The Voice from heaven | Sure, NBC’s buzzy singing competition doesn’t feature any “bad” vocalists, but what about when you compare ‘em to the woman who was frequently referred to as “THE VOICE”? Who better to point guns of harsh truth at the wannabes tackling “I Will Always Love You” and “I Have Nothing” — and maybe bring a copyright-infringement suit against the show and network itself?

2 | Or alternately, Whitney descends from heaven to heckle Jennifer Lopez judging American Idol |Imagine one of the most celebrated power balladeers in music history having a laugh over the tinny-voiced dancer sitting in judgment of other singers? This one’s almost too easy.

(Head to Deadline to read Michale's two other suggestions for SNL writers.)

Despite the conjecture, a rep for the show refuses to expand on the possibility. “As you know, the show never comments on potential show content,” said the spokesperson. “As Maya impersonated Whitney, it’s a natural question, but one [to which] we do not have an answer.”

What do you think, Instincters? Is it too soon for SNL and Maya to produce a Whitney Houston sketch, even if done tastefully? Or could a tribute that inspires us to laugh (often said to be the best medicine) in a sensitive manner actually work?

Comments (7)Add Comment
0
...
written by JL Louie , February 15, 2012
Would Michael's feel offended having the world "mocking" his parents passing , or his children days after their tragic loss. Give it a rest SNL !
MWood
...
written by BrandonJ, February 15, 2012
This goes too far, SNL. Don't do it.
0
...
written by Randman254, February 15, 2012
I would be quite offened at this. Let the woman rest in peace. I am sure they had enough impersonating her when she was at her low points. She is gone and her family is grieving, now is not the time, nor is any other time from now on.
0
...
written by nol, February 15, 2012
I dont mind SNL doing a Whitney sketch. They have never been known to be overly crass with a real sensitive subject. But good lord Maya Rudolph does the worst whitney houston impression ever! let someone else do it! And dont let it be crass.
0
...
written by MDaveH1969, February 15, 2012
Making a funny situation over someone people are mourning is not cool. It was fine while she was alive, but not anymore. Maya Rudolph needs to come up with a new skit to replace Whitney in her repertoire.
0
...
written by x, February 15, 2012
Is there no compassion and empathy left in the world? Everything is not funny. Everything is not one big joke.
0
...
written by Asia, February 16, 2012
Maya, this is a bad move. You are talented but doing a skit on Whitney is pointless, tasteless and exploitive. By the way your Whitney impression is pretty awful!!!! So give the public a rest.

Write comment

busy
 
 
 
© 2009 Instinct Magazine  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Web Site By Nathan Grimes Design