This debate is hilarious. It's obvious that they cast the two actors who were ready to bare it all. Most good actors are extremely choosy before they would agree to go full frontal or even partial nude. Matt has said in one of the Magic Mike interviews that he would do that only for 2 directors.
They are frankly lucky to get the actors they did. This is a huge gamble imo. Esp. for Charlie who is a decent actor. Altho' don't get why they didn't cast Ian, he wanted it so bad.
Matt is one classy guy and I love what he said in those succinct words.
More information about text formats