Because we're not all the same, Benjamin. Being gay means we have a single thing in common: We're romantically and sexually interested in the same sex. It doesn't mean we share the same opinions about everything nor do we necessarily have anything else in common. A lot of black people were happy OJ was exonerated; that doesn't mean all black people were "okay with it." Personally, I think Eminem just sucks, both as an artist and a human being, and choose to ignore his existence. Some share my feelings, others choose to be more adamant about their dislike. Humans in general have a tendency to get uppity and even cruel about their dislikes.
More information about text formats