Supreme Court Won’t Hear Grimm Case On Transgender Rights
In a one-sentence order, the Supreme Court vacated an appeals court decision in favor of a Virginia transgender boy, Gavin Grimm, and sent the case back for further consideration in light of the new guidance from the administration.
For more on the history of Gavin Grimm's fight, head over to the New York Times.
What is your response to the SCOTUS backing away from hearing the case. Was it right for them to follow the lead of Trump and making Transgender rights a state only issue? The Los Angeles LGBT Center released the following statement on the U.S. Supreme Court’s Refusal to Hear Gavin Grimm’s Case.
LOS ANGELES, March 6, 2017— In response to the United States Supreme Court’s decision today not to hear the transgender rights case of Virginia student Gavin Grimm, Los Angeles LGBT Center Director of Policy and Community Building Dave Garcia issued the following statement:
“Today we are sadly reminded that justice deferred is justice denied. The announcement by the U.S. Supreme Court to send Gavin Grimm’s case back to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit is a direct result of the anti-LGBT actions of the Trump administration. Many of us feared the administration’s February 22 rollback of Title IX guidance for transgender students signaled darker days ahead. Today those fears are realized.
“This administration is dangerously out of step with the progress of our nation and world. Its early days have been marked by a rollout of an ultra-conservative, anti-equality agenda decades in the making—the tragic consequences of which our community feels sharply again today. While there is likely a more direct anti-LGBT executive order still to come, this administration is content in the meantime to chip away at equality by targeting some of the most vulnerable in our community.
“Three out of four transgender youth report feeling unsafe at school. More than 40 percent have been physically abused at school; more than half report skipping school to avoid bullying. Toxic schools contribute to higher rates of suicide, depression, homelessness, and HIV infection for transgender youth. Yet, every day transgender youth, like Gavin Grimm, stand up with a moral integrity and strength that is awe-inspiring. They deserve the dignity of being free from harassment and discrimination. We must do better for them.
“Don’t be fooled because this administration’s actions have been didactically masked by a paranoid flurry of nonsensical executive orders and mean tweets. They insidiously use words like ‘safety,’ ‘privacy,’ and ‘choice’ to justify their actions when, in fact, they are working against the values Americans hold most dearly: freedom, equality, and justice. We must see through the noise and continue to fight for justice.
“We know that the arc of the moral universe is long and that it bends toward justice. It won’t get there without our help. We must remain engaged and vigilant. If you believe in a world where all LGBT people can thrive as healthy, equal, and complete, then you must make sure your voice is heard. Only then will true equality prevail.”
is Trump a coward when it comes to making a decision on national transgender rights? Or is he being strong and pusing it back to states to fight out in order to build support as the case was with marriage equality?
In January the Center launched 100 Days and Me, a community engagement campaign to protect the health, freedom, and well-being of LGBT people. Visitors to 100DaysAndMe.org will find information about federal legislative and policy threats to LGBT people during the first 100 days of the Trump Administration. They can also register to receive updates and take advantage of resources and tools to respond to actions that would harm LGBT people.
For more information, visit 100DaysAndMe.org.