Home arrow Blogs arrow The Watercooler arrow American Idol Is Really Weird This Season
American Idol Is Really Weird This Season PDF  | Print |  EMail
Written by Alex Cho   
Wednesday, 21 May 2008

ImageI am SO not an American Idol fan. I've probably seen a grand total of four episodes—ever. So maybe that gives me a good perspective when I randomly tuned in recently to find a strange boy-creature with squinty eyes in the finals with a stoned, balding otter who sometimes plays guitar. (By that, I mean David Archuleta and David Cook.) What a strange finale!

We already know who's gonna win. Even David Cook admits it. When Archuleta becomes the next American Idol (because you know he will), I kinda want to see him become famous to see how far the cutesy boy act will take him. After that eventually winds up, he'll either turn into some kind of sexed-out Justin Timberlake wanna-be or a Michael Jackson-esque recluse. I bet the latter. Cuz you know his favorite quote is: "You'll never be lonely if you learn to befriend yourself." Mmm-hmm.

The more important question is: Why do I find David Cook kinda sexy? It's been bugging me since last week's return to each contestant's hometown. He's mildly talented, seems kinda dumb, and totally milquetoast. But there's something really simple about the way he talks—he seems kinda humble and grounded. And that's kinda hot. Plus, you know the quiet ones are always knockouts in bed. Maybe he knows it.

Image




Link to this...
Digg!Del.icio.us!Facebook!StumbleUpon!
Comments (11)add feed
...
written by krycek on May 21, 2008

Both are icky and boring.

...
written by krycek on May 22, 2008

Well, your boyfriend won.

...
written by Alex on May 22, 2008

Total sex.

...
written by Dave in Phoenix on May 22, 2008

This is the latest example from the gay "community" to further illustrate exactly why I am letting my subscription expire and that I do not consider myself part of that "community" at all. And by the way, the cover of the new issue of Instinct is another fine example - PINK enough for ya?? Geezus. Excuse me while I go vomit.

I think it's pathetic that any gay man could look at David Cook and not agree with "Alex" that he is "total sex," but yet you will never catch a member of the "community" saying anything negative about a female performer/contestant. If the finale had been Syesha and Brooke, you all would be screaming your gay asses off over how stunning, gorgeous, and sexy they are, and their outfits or shoes were to die for.

I have long considered myself the straightest gay man I know, and that annoying faggy BS is exactly why I am happy with that. You all should have been girls, or should become girls, because that's what you are.

...
written by Alex on May 23, 2008

Um... isn't the post about how David Cook is attractive?

Dave, there's a great magazine for gay guys who want to be straight - it's called "Maxim." Display it on your coffee table proudly!

...
written by Remy D on May 23, 2008

Well...while Dave in Phoenix goes and pretends to be straight at a NASCAR rally Alex, here's David Cook's Guitar Hero commercial at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h61egeG1-v4 It's a spin on Tom Cruise in Risky Business. BTW, I think it's his stubble that makes him strangely attractive.

...
written by Dave in Phoenix on May 23, 2008

It comes as no surprise that you don't understand me (hence why I will not renew my subscription.) I don't understand you either, so it's a draw.

...
written by Dave in Phoenix on May 23, 2008

Being gay - physically attracted to your own sex - does not require living a gay lifestyle. No gay magazine I've ever seen speaks to the type of gay man I am. I tried for 3 years to fit in and participate in the "community" via an empowerment program, but it was a constant uphill battle. I don't like the stereotypical stuff: drag, Britney, musicals, shopping, the color pink, clubbing, interior design, or Pride. Oh, and I don't want kids or marriage either.

I just like boys. Very simple. I don't understand why most gay men don't get that. I'm neither liberal nor conservative, I'm in the middle. I'm not a sports fan except for baseball. I grew up oppressed in Montana and did not fully realize my sexuality until I moved out of my parents house.

I am very proud of who I am. I think boys are fabulous and I wouldn't have it any other way. But the gay community is not for me.

...
written by Krycek on May 23, 2008

Yeah, so anyway...i wouldn't mind putting pigtails in David Cook's hair and playing Easy Bake cookie twirl! Wheeeeeeeee!

...
written by P DD on May 23, 2008

Dave, like you I don't like the stereotypical stuff: drag, Britney, musicals, shopping, the color pink, clubbing, interior design, or Pride.

But very much unlike you, I don't believe in gay bashing. There's no need to attack others for not being more like you.

Comments like "PINK enough for ya?? Geezus. Excuse me while I go vomit.", "that annoying faggy BS is exactly why I am happy with that" say alot more about you than how straight acting you are.

If Instinct is not for you, then fine. Cancel your subscription and get a subscritpion to something that speaks more to you.

But enough with the hate already.

...
written by Alex on May 24, 2008

Remy - thanks for the link! That *was* hot.

Tell us what you think, people! If your comments are posted, we reserve the right to use these comments in our Interaction (Letters) section of the published magazine. If your comments are published in the magazine, we may edit your comments for length or clarity. Thank you!
password
 

busy