Israeli Woman Fined $140 Per Day For Refusing To Circumcise Son


Pictured above: A Plastibell device which can be used to circumcise young boys. Photo by David Levene


An Israeli woman who refused to "physically harm her son" by having the now one year old circumcised has been sentenced by a religious court to pay a fine of $140 per day until the procedure is performed. 

According to a report by Haaretz, the child's mother Elinor stated:

"The baby was born with a medical problem, so we couldn’t circumcise him on the eighth day as is customary. As time went on, I started reading about what actually happens in circumcision, and I realized that I couldn’t do that to my son. He’s perfect just as he is.”

We wish the story was as simple as a mother sticking up for her kid, but unfortunately, things get a little tricky (and messy)…

According, to Elinor, her husband originally supported the decision to not circumcise their son, but as they began discussing their divorce in rabbinical court (part of Jerusalem's justice system that oversees matters of religion, including marriage and divorce), he changed his mind. However, Jerusalem court judges believe that Elinor could be using the infant (and his boy parts) as a pawn in making headway in the divorce proceedings. 

By Jewish Law, if one parent wants their son to be circumcised, the other parent can't prevent it from taking place unless it's medically dangerous for the child. 

This case is the first time a religious court has slapped a fine on a parent for refusing the procedure that is in line with Jewish Law. 

Elinor, whose fine is now up to $700, plans to appeal the case to High Court of Justice in an effort to annul the rabbinical court's decision. 


Let's hope they can reach a resolution soon! This is one procedure that most men would prefer to not have memory of. 

Tell us Instincter's, which side of the knife are you on in this debate?


Image Source. (H/T:


What do you think?