Michael Caruso has landed in an especially grim political full-circle moment: the former Florida Republican legislator who voted for a law allowing the death penalty for certain child sex offenders is now facing five felony charges involving the alleged abuse of a child.
RELATED: Rudy Giuliani Goes After Mamdani’s Child Care With an Anti-Trans Rant
The 67-year-old former Republican Florida state legislator and Palm Beach County clerk was arrested Tuesday on five felony charges, including kidnapping, child molestation, lewd exhibition, luring or enticing a child, and child abuse causing mental injury, according to an arrest affidavit.
A married father of seven, was appointed Palm Beach County clerk of the circuit court and comptroller by Gov. Ron DeSantis in August 2025. DeSantis suspended him from office after learning of the allegations.
Investigators allege that Caruso sexually abused a child who is a relative on multiple occasions between fall 2024 and August 2025. The allegations reportedly involve family settings and outings, including a cruise, a fishing trip and Thanksgiving. The child has been receiving therapeutic services since April 2026, according to the affidavit.
The allegations are just that — allegations — and he is entitled to due process as the case moves through the courts. But the circumstances surrounding the arrest have created an especially uncomfortable political full-circle moment. Because he didn’t merely have a tough stance on child sex crimes. He voted for one of Florida’s toughest laws on them.
RELATED: Andy Ogles’ Anti-LGBTQ+ Politics Just Cost Him His Seat in Congress
Caruso voted for the death penalty
Back when Caruso represented District 87 in the Florida House, he voted in favor of legislation that became the 2023 Florida Capital Sexual Battery law. The measure allows prosecutors to seek the death penalty for adults convicted of sexually battering children under 12. Caruso’s vote is recorded as a “Yea” on the April 13, 2023, House vote.
DeSantis signed the legislation in May 2023, and it took effect six months later. So yes, the political irony here is doing most of the heavy lifting. But the law itself is also controversial. And following his arrest, the governor was asked the obvious question: The arrest has created an unsettling connection between Caruso’s legislative record and the allegations now facing him.
“It was a very easy decision for me to yank him from that position,” DeSantis said during a Tuesday news conference.
When asked whether he or anyone in his administration was aware of the allegations before Caruso’s appointment, he answered: “Of course not.”
“He had a clean vet, he was well-regarded in the community,” DeSantis said, calling the alleged crimes “horrific.”
Florida is the first state to reintroduce the death penalty for convicted pedophiles, DeSantis said, and if Caruso is convicted, “he is going to be in a world of hurt.” That is, to put it mildly, one way to describe a very bad day at the courthouse.
The allegations involve a family member
According to the arrest affidavit, the alleged victim is a child who is related to Caruso, and investigators say the alleged abuse happened multiple times between fall 2024 and August 2025. Authorities say the alleged abuse happened repeatedly, including during family activities. The affidavit describes alleged incidents connected to a family cruise, a fishing outing and a Thanksgiving gathering.
The affidavit says the child has been receiving therapeutic services since April. The Haba Law Firm, which represents the alleged victim, said it intends to make sure the child’s voice remains part of the proceedings.
“This arrest is a decisive line in the sand. When someone targets a child, they don’t just break the law — they shatter a community’s trust,” Lisa Haba said in a statement shared with Newsweek.
The language is stark because the allegations themselves are stark. Whatever political arguments surround Caruso, the criminal case ultimately concerns an alleged child victim — not a campaign slogan or legislative voting record.
The DeSantis connection gets awkward
Caruso’s arrest has also put his relatively recent appointment under a brighter spotlight. DeSantis selected him to become Palm Beach County clerk and comptroller in August 2025. He was already a familiar figure in Florida Republican politics after serving in the state House. The governor said there was nothing in Caruso’s background check that alerted the administration to the allegations.
“He had a clean vet, he was well-regarded in the community,” DeSantis said.
Caruso was also seeking reelection to the clerk’s position. He was not facing a Republican primary challenger, but the Florida GOP has now called on him to withdraw from the race. The clerk’s office, meanwhile, emphasized that the allegations against him do not change its work.
“While this is surprising news for our entire team, it does not change who we are at the Clerk’s Office or our commitment to the community and customers we serve,” the Palm Beach County Clerk of the Circuit Court & Comptroller’s Office said in an email to Newsweek.
Shannon Ramsey-Chessman was sworn in as clerk ad interim following Caruso’s suspension.
Now the law Caruso supported is part of the conversation
There is something undeniably jarring about the juxtaposition. A Republican politician who once cast a vote supporting the death penalty for certain child sex offenders is now accused of crimes involving a child. But it is important not to confuse political irony with a verdict. Caruso has been charged, not convicted, and the allegations will have to be established in court.
What happens next will be decided by the criminal justice system — the same system he once helped shape from a legislative seat. He was booked into the Orange County jail and is being held without bond. Investigators say the case remains ongoing and that additional charges are possible.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier offered a reminder that public office doesn’t come with a special exemption from scrutiny.
“Being in a position of public trust provides no shield from accountability,” state Attorney General James Uthmeier said. “This individual will face the full force of the law.”
The contrast is difficult to miss: Caruso once voted for a law allowing prosecutors to seek the death penalty in certain child sexual battery cases. Now he is the subject of a criminal investigation involving allegations of child sexual abuse. But beneath all the political irony, appointments, campaign plans and legislative votes, there is a much more serious issue: an alleged child abuse case that investigators are still building.
And that, rather than the political theater surrounding it, is where the attention belongs.
Source: Newsweek