In a move that’s as satisfying as a rainbow-colored confetti cannon, the U.S. Supreme Court has rejected former Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis’ appeal to overturn the landmark 2015 Obergefell v. Hodges ruling that legalized same-sex marriage nationwide. It was a decision so definitive that it left no room for doubt—Kim Davis’ fight against marriage equality isn’t just over; it’s done and dusted.
RELATED: Cohen vs. Kim Davis: The Marriage Equality Clapback We Needed
The Battle Begins: Kim Davis vs. Marriage Equality
For the uninitiated (or those who’ve intentionally blocked her out of their memory), Davis made headlines back in 2015 when she refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, citing her religious beliefs. In the wake of Obergefell, which mandated marriage equality across the country, Davis took a stand that seemed to scream “tradition” with a side of “no, thank you” to the Constitution. But her actions, and her refusal to comply with the law, eventually led to a courtroom battle that would span years.
One of the couples she refused to serve, David Ermold and David Moore, sued her, resulting in a jury awarding them $100,000 in emotional distress damages, plus $260,000 in legal fees. And yet, despite a jail stint and a defeat in court, Davis kept on battling. Her most recent appeal to the Supreme Court was her last-ditch effort to have the Obergefell ruling overturned altogether—essentially asking the highest court to erase the right of same-sex couples to marry, as if it were just a mistake that could be “fixed.”
Supreme Court Says ‘No’: Davis’ Appeal Denied
“The Court can and should fix this mistake,” Davis’ attorneys argued. Because, naturally, the matter of whether or not gay people can marry is still somehow up for debate in 2025. (Spoiler alert: it’s not.)
But in the end, the justices weren’t having it. They issued a brief order rejecting her appeal, which means, once again, that Obergefell stands. In fact, the court didn’t even have to deliberate on the issue, leaving no room for dissent. As they say in the world of legal jargon, “next case.”
The fact that the conservative majority on the Court didn’t take the bait wasn’t a huge surprise, but that didn’t stop some LGBTQ+ rights groups from holding their breath. After all, a few of the justices who dissented in the original Obergefell decision remain on the bench—so the concern was real, though perhaps not entirely warranted this time.
The road to this conclusion has been anything but smooth. In 2015, Davis defied a judge’s order to issue marriage licenses, earning herself a five-day stint in jail, though she famously refused to budge on her stance. Kentucky even passed a law allowing clerks to remove their signatures from marriage certificates, so clerks like Davis could still make a statement without violating their personal beliefs. That law, however, didn’t stop Davis from dragging out her fight in court. She kept pressing for her religious freedom argument, claiming a First Amendment right to defy the law despite holding a government position.
The Final Word: Marriage Equality is Here to Stay
But now, the Court has drawn the line. And for the LGBTQ+ community, that’s a win not just for the law, but for the principle that marriage equality isn’t going anywhere, no matter how many Kim Davises are out there trying to stir the pot.
The case was a complex one, with a long history of legal battles and back-and-forths over the scope of religious freedom versus the rights of same-sex couples. Davis’ team, in particular, believed that if the Court could find in her favor on the religious freedom point, it would effectively render the case against her moot. However, the couple’s legal team pointed out that Davis had waived this argument earlier in the litigation. The issue was no longer whether she could argue her First Amendment rights, but whether she even had the legal standing to continue this fight. “The Court should hold her to that representation,” the couple’s attorneys wrote.
At the end of the day, the ruling is a reminder of the strength of Obergefell—and, for LGBTQ+ folks, a sweet confirmation that the fight for marriage equality isn’t going backward. After all, love is love, and there’s no reversing that truth. Not even Kim Davis can make it disappear with a legal appeal or a prayer.
So, what’s next? While Davis may have lost this battle, the ripple effects of such cases remind us that the struggle for full equality is ongoing. But one thing is clear: Same-sex marriage is here to stay, and no amount of legal wrangling is going to change that. The rainbow flags, love-filled weddings, and joyous celebrations will continue—because let’s face it: we’ve got more important things to do than to entertain the whims of the past.
Source: The Hill
Neve to be overturned ! Hear that Texas. The people can NOT refuse to marry SS couples! Gov. Abbott stated that in Texas the Texas Supreme Court rule they can! Nope, you can NOT over rule the US Supreme Court!! Go cry on Kim Davis shoulder, I’m sure she will accommdate you! LOL
Go ahead–mess with the LGBT community! We are the strongest community and when we come together to fight against prejudice ,or the government trying to remove or current rights ,they will lose. We will continue to fight for equal rights and TRY to educate the ignorant on our lifestyles (talk about a tough job!), and anyone dare try to intimidate , dismiss, or assault any of us will pay dearly. Try it. you shall regret it. From any single person all the way up to the Supreme Court or President!
I guess love is love, no matter which side of the rainbow you are on, and should be left alone, especially since God created love in the first place.
Felicitaciones la ley es ley
if you are such a staunch Christian you should be aware of God’s teaching that says judge not lest ye be judged “.
Well, you upstanding example of Christian Values and icon of the perfect marriage record you did judge and were judged back. This should put you in your place as you should believe that this is the will of your God and if you do not then we all have to bring your commitment to him as flawed and without any credibility. Sorry to judge but you started all this.
Kim Davis is truly a role model for the Christian right. She’s been married four times to three husbands. She has two daughters with her third husband and twins who were fathered by that third husband, but adopted by the man who became her second and fourth husband. She is a staunch Trump Republican. She is an Apostolic Pentecostal Christian, who believes that the Bible is infallible.
Yup, we should all take value lessons from that Kim Davis!
I think not!
A big, huge LOL to that homophobe davies.
maybe she should focus on other things.
one thing for sure, her god does hate her