The internet is buzzing with one very important question: Is Joe Keery bisexual? After a recent interview, some fans couldn’t help but wonder if the Stranger Things star was subtly sharing a bit more about his identity than he intended. And even though the question on everyone’s lips is, Is Joe Keery gay? — there’s no official confirmation, but the moment in question has certainly left the internet theorizing — and we’re here for it.
RELATED: Joe Keery Donates $1 Per Ticket to LGBTQ+ Youth
Keery, who’s known for playing Steve Harrington in Stranger Things, was in London promoting the show’s upcoming fifth and final season. Alongside co-stars like Winona Ryder and Millie Bobby Brown, Keery appeared on Hits Radio where things quickly took a playful turn. The cast was asked about their childhood crushes, leading to some very interesting (and confusing) answers.
RELATED: Stranger Things S5: Noah Schnapp Says it’s “The Gayest It’s Ever Been”
@hitsradiouk Hear them out ✋ The cast of @strangerthings joined @thenilaextract ahead of the release of season 5, out on @netflixuk on 27th November! 📺 #strangerthings #vecna #hearmeout
Keery’s Childhood Crush Confession
When asked about his crushes, Keery immediately brought up Disney’s animated Robin Hood, where the titular fox and Maid Marian—another fox—serve as the love interests. Seems pretty straightforward, right? Well, not exactly. His castmates, Jamie Campbell Bower and Natalia Dyer, started asking rapid-fire follow-up questions. Was he talking about the original 1938 Errol Flynn version, or the animated one? And which fox was he referring to—Robin Hood or Maid Marian?
Keery’s answer? “Both of them.” Now, we can all agree that both Robin Hood and Maid Marian are a bit of a crush-worthy duo (I mean, who doesn’t find an anthropomorphic fox with a bow and arrow attractive?), but the chaos of overlapping questions left some viewers thinking Keery was revealing more than just a simple childhood crush on animated animals.
The Speculation Begins: Bisexuality?
Enter the speculation: Was Keery casually hinting at his bisexuality? It’s not hard to see why some fans think so. The confusion of his answer paired with the fact that he’s openly supported LGBTQ+ charities made it easy for some to interpret the moment as a “soft launch” of his bisexuality. One person on Twitter even wrote, “Joe Keery soft-launching his bisexuality by talking about a cartoon crush is exactly how I came out to my family years ago, so as a fellow bi guy, this is very beautiful to me to be honest.” It’s not the first time Keery has sparked conversations like this. His quiet support for the LGBTQ+ community—through both his words and actions—makes this playful exchange seem like more than just an accident.
Keery’s LGBTQ+ Support Fuels the Rumors
Of course, the actor hasn’t confirmed anything officially, and it’s entirely possible he was just making an innocent joke. But hey, this kind of playful ambiguity feels oddly familiar to anyone who’s ever come out in a nonchalant, almost accidental way. It’s a relatable experience for many—sometimes our sexuality is revealed in the least expected of places, even when we’re not quite ready to define it.
As if the animated crushes weren’t enough, Keery also confessed to having a soft spot for Space Jam’s Lola Bunny, which, frankly, could be considered a whole other article. “I remember being like ‘Excuse me?!’” Keery said, reflecting on his initial reaction to the character’s seductive design. Dyer and Heaton jumped in, agreeing with the sentiment, calling Lola “hot” in a way that only true ‘90s kids would understand. It’s these candid and humorous moments that make Keery such an endearing figure to fans. It’s almost like he’s opening a door to more personal sides of himself in the least obvious, yet incredibly charming, way.
The Cast’s Shared Chemistry and Playful Banter
The rest of the interview was a delightful dive into the gang’s shared crushes. Heaton recalled his own crush on Yu-Gi-Oh’s Yami in Pharaoh form, while Campbell Bower reminisced about his obsession with Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Classic. It’s clear that these actors have a lot of fun together, and their chemistry shines through in the lightheartedness of their discussion.
Could This Be Keery’s Quiet Coming Out? Maybe Not—But We’re Watching
But beyond the jokes and nostalgic crush talk, there’s something heartwarming about Keery’s casual yet inclusive approach to these conversations. He’s not just another actor talking about his childhood heroes — he’s showing up for the LGBTQ+ community in his own quirky way, whether or not he’s consciously “coming out.” It’s this authenticity, this willingness to just be himself without trying too hard to fit a specific mold, that makes him even more relatable.
Stranger Things season 5, the show’s final season, is set to debut on November 26, and with the cast’s clear camaraderie and openness, we’re sure to see more moments that make us smile, question, and maybe even get a little nostalgic. For now, though, we’ll just be over here wondering about Keery’s next “soft launch” — because it’s clear the Stranger Things cast has a lot more to offer than just Upside Down drama.
Maybe we’ll find out more about Joe Keery in season five. Or maybe we’ll just get more animated foxes and Lola Bunny. Either way, we’re here for it.