A devastating car crash outside a well-known gay bar, Bradley’s, in Florida, has left five people dead and 13 others injured.
The tragedy occurred after a high-speed police chase that has since raised serious questions about how local authorities handled the situation. Both the Florida Highway Patrol (FHP) and the Tampa Police Department (TPD) were involved in the pursuit, which ended just steps away from one of the city’s busiest nightlife districts. Critics and investigators are now examining conflicting statements made by both agencies about when the chase ended — and whether officers’ actions unnecessarily put lives at risk.
RELATED: Tragedy at a Tampa Gay Bar: A Safe Space Shattered
Conflicting Reports from Tampa Authorities
Initial reports from the Tampa Police Department claimed that the pursuit ended before the suspect’s vehicle reached Nebraska Avenue. However, footage captured by WTSP’s news drone and police helicopter recordings tell a different story. The video shows that the Florida Highway Patrol actually performed a precision immobilization technique (PIT) — a maneuver used to stop fleeing vehicles — hundreds of feet past Nebraska Avenue. Even more concerning, the footage reveals that troopers continued to follow the suspect into 7th Avenue, a heavily populated area filled with bars and pedestrians, mere seconds before the crash occurred. Both the TPD and FHP have so far declined to answer questions about these discrepancies.
Criticism from Former Law Enforcement and Legal Experts
Former police instructor Tom Gleason, who taught vehicle pursuit tactics at the Florida Highway Patrol academy, condemned the decision to carry out a high-speed chase through such a crowded area.
“We can always apprehend a person at a later date, but we can’t bring people back to life,” said Gleason.
He pointed out that a police helicopter was already tracking the suspect’s car, meaning there was no need for an on-ground chase. According to Gleason, the risks were simply too high, especially in a nightlife district like Ybor City where large weekend crowds are common. Legal experts have echoed this concern, including attorney Anthony Rickman, who stated that the Florida Highway Patrol’s broad pursuit policy has led to an increase in fatalities from similar incidents.
Officials Defend Troopers’ Actions
The Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles released a statement defending the officers involved. Spokesperson Madison Kessler said that the troopers “followed policy, disengaged prior to when the suspect entered a crowded area, and the driver lost control on his own.” Another state official told WTSP that “troopers and FHP will give no quarter to those who terrorize roadways and communities” and that troopers “will continue to put themselves at risk to protect others.” However, the timeline revealed by independent video footage has led many to question whether disengagement happened soon enough to prevent the tragedy.
Suspect Faces Multiple Felony Charges
The driver, 22-year-old Silas Sampson, was taken into custody and is now facing eight felony charges, including four counts of vehicular homicide. Authorities say Sampson’s vehicle was speeding when it crashed into the outdoor seating area at Bradley’s, instantly turning a typical weekend night into chaos. Witnesses have described the aftermath as “devastating,” with first responders rushing to assist multiple victims.
Community Demands Accountability
The incident has deeply shaken Tampa’s LGBTQ+ community, with many calling for transparency and accountability from both the TPD and FHP.
Bradley’s, a longtime safe space for queer locals and visitors, has become an emotional center for grieving families, survivors, and residents demanding answers. As investigations continue, questions remain about whether this tragedy could have been prevented — and whether police pursuit policies in Florida need urgent reform.
REFERENCE: Tampa.gov, WTSP, Hoodline