Hallmark’s Finding Mr. Christmas is Back for a Fun-Filled Season 2!

Hallmark

The hit Hallmark reality series returns October 27th with a season full of, well, hot men. Listen, this is a gay man’s website, so I’m not going to focus solely on their acting resumes. Especially when they’re all very, very attractive. But, just in case you missed it last year, Finding Mr. Christmas searches for the next big heartthrob to lead a movie in the annual Hallmark Christmas movie saga. Hosted by Jonathan Bennett and Melissa Peterman, Finding Mr. Christmas is full of acting challenges, heartfelt moments and holiday shenanigans. 

Advertisement

To its credit, Hallmark definitely kept its promise last year when the hosts and producers picked Ezra Moreland as the season one winner. Moreland was the lead actor in 2024’s Happy Howlidays and, thanks to his muscles, he’s going to star in Christmas on Duty due out in a few weeks. Finding Mr. Christmas serves as the perfect launch pad for young actors, but it’s up to the winners to decide if they’re going to stay with Hallmark or jump to other networks. Hey, don’t bite the hand that feeds you, right? I wonder if Ezra will make a guest appearance during season two. 

The new season starting on October 27th, which airs on Hallmark & Hallmark+, seems to have a really cool dynamic this year. The cast is full of first-timers, independent actors, seasoned professionals and… NFL players? Yes, you read that correctly. Again, it’s a launch pad for aspiring actors and that includes people from all walks of life – which is also kind of Hallmark’s deal. Inclusive holiday movies. Oh, my god. I see what they did here! Okay, back to the hot men. 

Related Post: Hallmark is Looking For Holiday Hunks In A New Reality Show – Instinct Magazine

Advertisement

Here’s the men of Hallmark’s Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2. They weren’t listed based on looks or resume – but I did include shirtless photos and big career credits. They were listed based on alphabetical order of the last name. Because then you can’t yell at me if your favorite isn’t first. Let’s get to it! 

Hallmark Hotties

1. Marcus Brodie
marcusb
2. Davey Fisher
daveyf
3. Angel Garet – Known for recurring on First Wives Club and he’s already appeared in a holiday movie, A Nashville Christmas Carol

Advertisement
angelg
4. Craig Geoghan – Appeared in How I Met Your Father and was the love interest in a Carrie Underwood video
craigg
5. Drake Kuyper
drakek
6. Rustin Sailors
rustins
7. Jake Schum – former punter for The Cleveland Browns and New York Jets
Advertisement
jakes
8. Logan Shephard – he’s done a few horror films and Harry Potter fan films which are two of my favorite things
logans
9. Robbie Simpson – guest starred in numerous episodes of General Hospital so this is the perfect next stop
robbies
10. Gabriel Thaxton

Advertisement

Source:

Hallmark’s ‘Finding Mr. Christmas’ Is Back for Season 2: Meet Contestants

1 thought on “Hallmark’s Finding Mr. Christmas is Back for a Fun-Filled Season 2!”

  1. I don’t get it!. What’s the porpuse of this TV Show? Is the show trying to make fun of us gay people?
    All the candidates are straight, homphobes, transphobics, republicans, mysoginists, ultraconservatives, and they are Donald Trump and MAGA followers. They are not LGBT persons. What does it matter! All the muscle, handsome, and masculine men are straight. No one is homosexual.

    Reply

Leave a Comment