Andrew Scott Could Make Oscar History for Gay Actors

Written by

Published Nov 20, 2026

google preferred source badge dark

Andrew Scott could be about to give Hollywood a much-needed history lesson. The industry has never exactly been short of gay talent, but it has been rather slower when it comes to celebrating openly gay men in its most prestigious acting category. With his latest performance, Scott is giving the Academy a rather interesting opportunity to finally change that.

Scott
Photos are credited and source linked in the following individual photos below

The Fleabag star is attracting serious awards attention for Elsinore, a biographical drama in which he plays Ian Charleson, the Scottish actor best known for his portrayal of Hamlet at the National Theatre. Set against the backdrop of Charleson’s battle with AIDS, the film explores the personal struggles behind one of the most important performances of his career.

RELATED: Andrew Scott Backs ‘Heated Rivalry’ but Says Gay History Matters

Scheduled for release in UK cinemas on January 29, 2027, Elsinore has already generated considerable Oscar speculation. Some critics have suggested Scott has “all but secured” an Oscar, potentially putting him in contention to become the first openly gay man to win Best Actor at the Academy Awards.

orshot 1795091752342

Scott, understandably, isn’t rushing to plan his acceptance speech.

Speaking to WSJ. Magazine about the possibility, he said: “I don’t feel like I have to say anything about that, because the statistic speaks for itself.”

And what a statistic it is. Out gay men have received Best Actor nominations before, including Colman Domingo for Sing Sing and Rustin, and Sir Ian McKellen for Gods and Monsters. Neither took home the award. The distinction isn’t that gay actors have never delivered Oscar-worthy performances. It’s that an openly gay man has yet to win Hollywood’s biggest acting prize.

RELATED: Annie Proulx Reveals the Origin of ‘Brokeback Mountain’ Gay Romance

Andrew Scott doesn’t need to play by Hollywood’s old rules

Scott’s career has hardly been confined to one type of character. From the dangerously charming Moriarty in Sherlock to the priest who sent Fleabag viewers into collective emotional disarray, he’s built a reputation for performances that stick around long after the credits.

EMBED https://x.com/janemwilson/status/1207863294373040128/video/1 

Gay audiences have also had plenty to appreciate in his more recent work. He starred opposite Paul Mescal in All of Us Strangers, one of those films that can leave you staring at a wall for the rest of the evening, and took on a rather more sexually mischievous role as a therapist and hookup in It Gets Worse.

 

With Elsinore, however, Scott steps into the life of a real actor whose experiences were shaped by a very different era for gay men in entertainment.

x post 1.5x postspark 2026 11 19 20 36 06

Charleson never publicly came out during his lifetime. Diagnosed with HIV in 1986, he died from AIDS-related complications on January 6, 1990, aged 40. He specifically requested that his cause of death be made public to help raise awareness.

It’s a particularly poignant role for Scott, who has been publicly out since 2013. But he isn’t approaching Charleson’s story with the benefit of hindsight or judging him for the choices he made in an industry where being openly gay could come at a considerable professional cost.

Play

Scott also pushed back against the idea that his sexuality somehow limits the characters he can portray, saying: “I felt like I’ve got an understanding of what my failings are and what my strengths are. And I’ve never felt that it was beyond my reach to play a straight part.”

Frankly, the idea that an actor’s sexuality should determine which characters they can convincingly play feels like a conversation Hollywood should have retired some time ago.

Oscar history has a complicated relationship with being out

There’s an important distinction between LGBTQ+ performers winning Oscars and openly gay men winning Best Actor while publicly out. The Academy has recognised LGBTQ+ talent across its acting categories, but that particular milestone remains unclaimed.

x post 1.5x postspark 2026 11 19 20 37 11

Joel Grey, who won Best Supporting Actor for Cabaret in 1973, didn’t publicly come out until 2015. John Gielgud, who won the same category for Arthur in 1982, was a gay man whose sexuality had become public decades before his Oscar win, following his 1953 conviction for homosexual activity.

x post 1.5x postspark 2026 11 19 20 37 23

orshot 1795091867097

Jodie Foster collected two Best Actress Oscars, for The Accused and The Silence of the Lambs, before publicly acknowledging her sexuality. Marlon Brando, meanwhile, spoke about his experiences with men but never publicly identified as bisexual.

x post 1.5x postspark 2026 11 19 20 37 53

Their achievements are part of LGBTQ+ history, even if the circumstances surrounding their private lives were considerably different from those of openly gay performers today.

That’s why Scott’s potential victory would carry a different kind of significance. It wouldn’t erase the contributions of LGBTQ+ actors who came before him, but it would mark a moment in which an openly gay man could receive recognition in a category where that distinction has remained conspicuously absent.

For now, Scott seems content to let the performance speak for itself. And perhaps that’s the best approach. The Academy still has to make its decision, and Oscar predictions have a habit of becoming very awkward very quickly.

orshot 1795091896491

Still, if Elsinore does take Scott all the way to the podium, it would be a pretty extraordinary moment for an actor who has never needed to hide who he is to convince audiences of who he’s playing.


Source: WSJ Magazine, BFI, and AP

Leave a Comment